You are here

Fuzzy Performance Evaluation with AHP and Topsis Methods: Evidence from Turkish Banking Sector after the Global Financial Crisis

Journal Name:

Publication Year:

Abstract (2. Language): 
Banking sector plays a crucial role in economies. As a financial institution that leads the economy and investments, the performance measurement of the bank concerns different segments of the society. The main purpose of the study is to provide decision support for decision makers about the performance of banks by using multi criteria decision making techniques. In according with this purpose, the financial performance of twelve commercial banks are evaluated in terms of seventeen financial performance indicators by employing Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (henceforth Fuzzy AHP) and Fuzzy Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (henceforth Fuzzy TOPSİS) methods. The findings of the study show that these two methods rank banks in a similar manner.



Aebi, Vincent; Sabata, G. & Schmid, M. (2011) “Risk Management, Corporate Governance
and Banks Performance in the Financial Crisis.” Journal of Banks and Finance, Forthcoming
Issue, 1-14
Aikhatklan, K. & Malik, Syed A. (2010) “Are Saudi Banks Efficient? Evidence Using Data
Envelopment Analysis.” International Journal of Economics and Finance, 2: 53-58
Akal, Z. (1996) İşletmelerde Performans Ölçüm ve Denetimi: Çok Yönlü Performans
Göstergeleri. Milli Prodüktivite Merkezi Yayınları, No.473
Alonso, J. A. & Lamata, M. T. (2006) “Consistency in the Analytic Hierarchy Process: A New
Approach.” International Journal of Uncertainty, Fuzziness and Knowledge-Based Systems,
14: 445-459
Fuzzy Performance Evaluation with AHP and Topsis Methods…
EJBE 2013, 6 (11) Page | 71
Al-Taleb, G. & Al-Shubiri, F. N. (2010) “A Comparison of Financial Performance in the
Jordanian Commercial Banks.” Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in
Business, 2: 258-280
Ashrafzadeh, M., Rafici, F. M., Isfahani, N. M. & Zare, Z. (2012) “Application of Fuzzy Topsis
Method for the Selection of Warehouse Location: A Case Study.” Interdisciplinary Journal of
Contemporary Research in Business, 3: 655-671
Atkinson, A., Waterhouse, J. H. & Wells, R. B. (1997) “A Stakeholder Approach To Strategic
Performance Measurement.” Sloan Management Review, 38: 25-37
Aydın, Ö. & Arslan, G. (2010) “Optimal Hospital Location With Fuzzy AHP.” The Business
Review Cambridge, 15: 262-268
Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (BRSA), (2011) Financial Market Report Issue: 24
Boran, F. E., Genç, S., Kurt, M. & Akay, D. (2009) “A Multi Criteria Intuitionistic Fuzzy Group
Decision Making for Supplier Selection With TOPSİS Method.” Expert Systems With
Applications, 36: 11363-11368
Bottani, E. & Rizzi, A. (2006) “A Fuzzy TOPSİS Methodology to Support Outsourcing of
Logistics Services.” Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 11/4: 294-308
Bozbura, T. F., Beskese, A. & Kahraman, C. (2007) “Prioritization of Human Capital
Measurement Indicators Using Fuzzy AHP.” Expert Systems with Applications, 32: 1100-1112
Büyüközkan, G. & Çiftçi, G. (2012) “A Combined Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy TOPSİS Based Strategic
Analysis of Electronic Service Quality in Healthcare Industry.” Expert Systems with
Applications, 39: 2341-2354
Büyüközkan, G., Çiftçi, G. & Güleryüz, S. (2011) “Strategic Analysis of Healthcare Service
Quality Using Fuzzy AHP Methodology.” Expert Systems With Applications, 38: 9407-9424
Chamodrakas, I., Batis, D. & Martakos, D. (2010) “Supplier Selection in Electronic
Marketplaces Using Satisficing and Fuzzy AHP.” Expert Systems With Applications,
37: 490-498
Chang, D.Y. (1996) “Application of the Extent Analysis Method on Fuzzy AHP.” European
Journal of Operational Research, 95: 649-655
Chang, D. Y. Zhu, K. J. & Jing, Y. (1999) “A Discussion on Extent Analysis Method and
Applications of Fuzzy AHP.” European Journal of Operational Research, 116: 450-456
Che, Z.H., Wang, H.S. & Chuang, C. L. (2010) “A Fuzzy AHP and DEA Approach for Marketing
Bank Loan Decisions for Small and Medium Enterprises in Taiwan.” Expert Systems With
Applications, 37: 7189-7199
Chen, C. T. (2000) “Extensions of the TOPSİS for Group Decision Making Under Fuzzy
Environment.” Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 114: 1-9
Chen, C. T., Lin, C. T. & Huang, S. F. (2006) “A Fuzzy Approach for Supplier Evaluation and
Selection in Supply Chain Management.” International Journal of Production Economics,
102: 289-301
Cheng, J. Z., Chen, P. T. & Yu, H. C. D. (2005) “Establishing a Man Access Strategy for Future
Broadband Service: A Fuzzy MCDM Analysis of SONET/SDH and Gigabit Ethernet.”
Technovation, 25: 557-567
Page | 72 EJBE 2013, 6 (11)
Chou, Y. C., Sun, C. C. & Yen, H. Y. (2012) “Evaluating the Criteria for Human Resource for
Science and Technology (HRST) Based on an Integrated Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy DEMATEL
Approach.” Applied Soft Computing, 12: 64-71
Çelik, M., Er, I. D. & Ozok, F. A. (2009) “Application of Fuzzy Extended AHP Methodology on
Shipping Registry Selection: The Case of Turkish Maritime Industry.” Expert Systems With
Applications, 36: 190-198
Dağdeviren, M., Yavuz, S. & Kılınç, N. (2009) “Weapon Selection Using the AHP and TOPSİS
Methods Under Fuzzy Environment.” Expert Systems With Applications, 36: 8143-8151
Dinçer, H., Gencer, G., Orhan, N. & Şahinbaş, K. (2011) “A Performance Evaluation of the
Turkish Banking Sector After the Global Crisis via CAMELS Ratios.” Procedia Social and
Behavioral Sciences, 24: 1530-1545
Enea, M. & Piazza, T. (2004) “Project Selection by Constrained Fuzzy AHP.” Fuzzy
Optimization and Decision Making, 3: 39-62
Girginer, N. (2008) “Ticari Kredi Taleplerinin Değerlendirilmesine Çok Kriterli Yaklaşım: Özel
ve Devlet Bankası Karşılaştırması.” Muhasebe ve Finansman Dergisi, 37: 132-141
Gregoriou, G. N., Lusk, E. J. & Halperin, M. (2008) “A Two Staged Benchmarked Decision
Support System Using DEA Profiles of Efficiency.” Infor, 46: 177-187
Güngör, Z., Serhadlıoğlu, G. & Kesen, S. (2009) “A Fuzzy AHP Approach to Personnel
Selection Problem.” Applied Soft Computing, 9: 641-646
Harnando, I. & Nieto, M. J. (2007) “Is the Internet Delivery Channel Changing Banks’
Performance? The Case of Spanish Banks.” Journal of Banking and Finance, 31: 1083-1099
Heo, E., Kim, J. & Boo, K. J. (2007) “Analysis of the Assessment Factors for Renewable Energy
Dissemination Program Evaluation Using Fuzzy AHP.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy
Reviews, 14: 2214-2220
İç, Y. T. & Yurdakul, M. (2010) “Development of a Quick Credibility Scoring Decision Support
System Using Fuzzy Topsis.” Expert Systems With Applications, 37: 567-574
Jahanshahloo, G.R., Lotfi, F. H. & Zadikhah, M. (2006) “Extension of the Topsis Method for
Decision Making Problems With Fuzzy Data.” Applied Mathematics and Computation, 181:
Jemric, I. & Vujcic, B. (2002) “Efficiency of Banks in Croatia: A DEA Approach.” Comperative
Economic Studies, 44: 169-193
Jyoti, B. D. K & Deshmukh, S.G. (2008) “Evaluating Performance of National R&D
Organizations Using Integrated DEA-AHP Technique.” International Journal of Productivty
and Performance Management, 57: 370-388
Kahraman, C., Ateş, N. Y., Çevik, S., Gülbay, M. & Erdoğan, A. (2007) “Hierarchical Fuzzy
Topsis Model for Selection Among Logistics Information Technologies.” Journal of Enterprise
Information Management, 20: 143-168
Kantor, J. & Maital, S. (1999) “Measuring Efficiency by Product Group: Integrating DEA with
Activity Based Accounting in a Large Mideast Bank.” Interfaces, 29: 27-36
Kaya, T. & Kahraman, C. (2011) “Multicriteria Decision Making in Energy Planning Using a
Modified Fuzzy Topsis Methodology.” Expert Systems With Applications, 38: 6577-6585
Kelemenis, A., Ergazakis, K. & Askounis, D. (2011) “Support Managers’ Selection Using an
Extension of Fuzzy Topsis.” Expert Systems With Applications, 38: 2774-2782
Kılınçcı, Ö. & Önal, S. A. (2011) “Fuzzy AHP Approach for Supplier Selection in a Washing
Machine Compony.” Expert Systems With Applications, 38: 9656-9664
Fuzzy Performance Evaluation with AHP and Topsis Methods…
EJBE 2013, 6 (11) Page | 73
Krishnendu, S., Shankar, R., Yadav, S. S. & Thakur, L. S. (2012) “Supplier Selection Using Fuzzy
AHP and Fuzzy Multi-Objective Linear Programming for Developing Low Carbon Supply
Chain.” Expert Systems With Applications, 39: 8182-8192
Kumar, S. & Gulati, R. (2010) “Measuring Efficiency, Effectiveness and Performance of Indian
Public Sector Banks.” International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management,
59: 51-74
Kwong, C.K. & Bai, H. (2003) “Determining The Importance Weights for the Customer
Requirements in QFD Using a Fuzzy AHP with an Extent Analysis Approach.” IEE Transactions,
35: 619-626
Lee, A. H. I. (2009) “A Fuzzy Supplier Selection Model With the Consideration of Benefits
Opportunities, Costs and Risks.” Expert Systems With Applications, 36: 2879-2893
Li, J. & Chen, S. (2009) “Evaluating the Architectural Design Services by Using Fuzzy AHP.”
The Business Review Cambridge, 13: 129-137
Liao, C. N. & Kao, H. P. (2011) “An Integrated Fuzzy TOPSİS and MCGP Approach to Supplier
Selection in Supply Chain Management.” Expert Systems With Applications, 38: 10803-10811
Mangır, F. & Erdoğan S. (2011) “Comparison of Economic Performance Among Six Countries
in Global Financial Crisis: The Application of Fuzzy Topsis Method.” Economics, Management
and Financial Markets, 6: 122-136
McEachern, D. & Paradi, J. C. (2007) “Intra and Inter Country Bank Branch Assessment Using
DEA.” Journal of Productivity Analysis, 27: 123-136
Mittal, M. & Dhade, A. (2009) “Awareness and Perception of CAMEL Rating Across Banks:
Some Survey Evidence.” ICFAI Journal of Bank Management, 8: 51-63
Mohaghar, A., Fathi, M. R., Zarchi, M. K. & Omidian, A. (2012) “A Combined VİKOR-Fuzzy AHP
Approach to Marketing Strategy Selection.” Business Management and Strategy, 3: 13-27
Neely, A. (2005) “The Evolution Of Performance Measurement Research: Developments In
The Last Decade A Research Agenda For The Next.” International Journal Of Operations And
Production Management, 25: 1264-1277
Özkan, G.,; E. N. & Tektaş, A. (2006) “Efficiency Analysis of the Turkish Banking Sector in
Precrisis and Crisis Period: A DEA Approach.” Contemporary Economic Policy, 24: 418-431
Pathak, B. (2003) “A Comparison of the Financial Performance of Private Sector Banks.”
Finance India, 17: 1345-1356
Perçin, S. (2008) “Use of Fuzzy AHP for Evaluating the Benefits of Information Sharing
Decisions in a Supply Chain.” Journal of Enterprise Information Management, 21: 263-284
Saaty, T.L. & Vargas, L.G. (2000) Models, Methods, Concepts and Applications of the Analytic
Hierarchy Process, Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers
Saghafian, S. & Hejazi, R. (2005) “Multi Criteria Group Decision Making Using A Modified
Fuzzy TOPSİS Procedure.” CIMCA-IAWTIC’05, IEEE
Seçme, N. Y., Bayrakdaroğlu, A. & Kahraman, C. (2009) “Fuzzy Performance Evaluation in
Turkish Banking Sector Using Analytic Hierarchy Process and TOPSİS.” Expert Systems With
Applications, 36: 11699-11709
Shanian, A. & Savadogo, O. (2006) “TOPSİS Multiple Criteria Decision Support Analysis for
Material Selection of Metallic Bipolar Plates for Polymer Electrolyte Fuel Cell.” Journal of
Power Sources, 159: 1095-1104
Page | 74 EJBE 2013, 6 (11)
Shaverdi, M., Akbari, M. & Tafti, S. F. (2011) “Combining Fuzzy MCDM with BSC Approach in
Performance Evaluation of Iranian Private Banking Sector.” Advances in Fuzzy Systems,
Sultan, J., Bilal, M. & Abbas, Z. (2011) “Performance Measurement by Data Envelopment
Analysis: A Study of Banking Sector in Pakistan.” Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary
Research in Business, 2: 229-249
Sun, C. C. & Lin, G. T. R. (2009) “Using Fuzzy Topsis Method for Evaluating the Competitive
Advantages of Shopping Websites.” Expert Systems With Applications, 36: 11764-11771
Sun, C. C. (2010) “A Performance Evaluation Model by Integrating Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy
TOPSİS Methods.” Expert Systems with Applications, 37: 7745-7754
Şakar, B. (2006) “A Study on Efficiency and Productivity of Turkish Banks in İstanbul Stock
Exchange Using Malmquist DEA.” Journal of American Academy of Business, 8: 145-155
Ta, H. P. & Kar, Y. H. (2000) “A Study of Bank Selection Decisions in Singapore Using the
Analytical Hierarchy Process.” The International Journal of Bank Marketing, 18: 170-180
Tsolas, E. I. (2010) “Modelling Bank Branch Profitability and Effectiveness by means of DEA.”
International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 59: 432-451
Tzeng, G. H. & Huang, J. J. (2011) Multiple Attribute Decision Making Methods and
Applications, CRC Pres Taylor and Francis Group, A Chapman and Hall Book, Boca Raton
Uwuigbe, O. R. & Fakile, A. S. (2012) “The Effects of Board Size on Financial Performance of
Banks: A Study of Listed Banks in Nigeria.” International Journal of Economics and Finance, 4:
Wang, J. W., Cheng, C. H. & Huang, K. C. (2009) “Fuzzy Hierarchical TOPSİS for Supplier
Selection.” Applied Soft Computing, 9: 377-386
Wang, M. H. & Huang, T. H. (2007) “A Study on the Persistence of Farrell’s Efficiency
Measure under a Dynamic Framework.” European Journal of Operational Research, 180:
Weiguo, X. & Ming, L. (2008) “Empirical Research of M&A Impact on Chinese and American
Commercial Banks’ Efficiency Based on DEA Method.” Management Science and
Engineering, 2: 38-47
Wen, L. (2008) “The Accounting and Financial Performance of Non-State-Owned Chinese
Commercial Banks.” Journal of Performance Management, 21: 32-46
Xia, W. & Wu, Z. (2007) “Supplier Selection With Multiple Criteria in Volume Discount
Environments.” Omega, 35: 494-504
Yong-tao, T., Li-yin, S., Longston, C. & Liu, Y. (2010) “Construction Project Selection Using
Fuzzy Topsis Approach.” Journal of Modelling in Managements, 5: 302-315
Yurdakul, M. & İç, Y. T. (2004) “AHP Approach in the Credit Evaluation of the Manufacturing
Firms in Turkey.” International Journal of Production Economics, 88: 269-289
Zadeh, L.A. (1965) “Fuzzy Sets.” Information and Control, 8: 338-353
Zeydan, M. & Çolpan, C. (2009) “A New Decision Support System for Performance
Measurement Using Combined Fuzzy TOPSİS/DEA Approach.” International Journal of
Production Research, 47: 4327-4349
Zouggari, A. & Benyoucef, L. (2012) “Simulation Based Fuzzy TOPSİS Approach for Group
Multi Criteria Supplier Selection Problem.” Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence,
25: 507-519

Thank you for copying data from